Supreme Pizza

Located conveniently on Boston Post Rd in Waterford, CT, Supreme Pizza is a beloved local pizza restaurant that has earned its reputation for consistently outstanding food and friendly service. With a menu that artfully balances classic pizza favorites with hearty grinders and comforting pasta dishes, this spot is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic, satisfying Italian-American fare.

The heart of Supreme Pizza’s appeal lies in its expertly crafted pizzas. Whether you opt for the indulgently cheesy Double Cheese slice or the timeless crowd-pleaser Pepperoni Pizza, you’re treated to a delightful sensory experience. Each slice boasts a perfect crust that strikes a charming balance between a satisfying crunch and a soft, pillowy interior—exactly how great pizza should be. The cheese is rich and flavorful, melting beautifully to create layers of gooey goodness that linger on the palate. Customers consistently praise the quality of ingredients and the generous portions, meaning you’ll leave feeling both nourished and delighted.

The menu extends beyond pizza to include an impressive variety of grinders—sandwiches packed with fresh, vibrant fillings. The Sausage and Peppers Grinder and the Philly Cheese Steak are standout options, each bursting with hearty flavors and prepared with care. One reviewer affectionately noted that a single sandwich is so substantial you can enjoy half for dinner and save the rest for lunch, a testament to the generous servings Supreme Pizza offers.

Pasta lovers will find comfort in the restaurant’s baked specialties like the classic Baked Ziti and the more indulgent Pasta with Eggplant Parmesan, which boasts a lovely balance of savory tomato sauce and tender, lightly fried eggplant. These dishes bring a warming, home-cooked feel that complements the vibrant main menu.

Supreme Pizza also rounds out the meal with tempting dessert choices like creamy Rice Pudding and rich Brownies, perfect for satisfying any sweet tooth after a hearty meal.

Beyond the food, the atmosphere at Supreme Pizza creates a warm invitation to relax and enjoy. The staff’s genuine friendliness and respect for one another create a welcoming environment where customers feel like part of the community. This genuine hospitality shines through in every interaction, making visits here memorable beyond just the plate.

Regulars sing the praises of the restaurant’s consistent quality and friendly vibe. Jeffrey Dorwart highlights the combination of excellent portions and well-prepared meals, calling it one of his go-to takeout spots. Another patron, Taylor, raves that Supreme Pizza ranks among Connecticut’s top 15 pizza places, celebrating the flavorful cheese and perfectly textured crust without the excessive grease found elsewhere. Ken Morris’s enthusiasm for both pizza and sandwiches showcases the diverse appeal, while Nikki Petrucci’s glowing review of the generous toppings and standout Greek salad confirms the care supreme kitchens take in crafting balanced, flavorful dishes.

Whether you’re a fan of a classic pepperoni slice, craving a sturdy grinder stuffed with savory meats and cheeses, or looking to indulge in a hearty pasta dinner, Supreme Pizza promises a reliably satisfying dining experience that feels like a warm, flavorful hug from a trusted hometown favorite.

Supreme Pizza is not just a place to eat—it’s a community staple that delivers both comfort and quality with every bite.